Big week in the world of college football polls as the BCS standings came out today
AP Top 5: LSU, Alabama, Oklahoma, Wisconsin, Boise State
Coaches' Top 5: Oklahoma, LSU, Alabama, Wisconsin, Stanford
Harris Top 5: LSU, Alabama, Oklahoma, Wisconsin, Boise State
BCS Top 5: LSU, Alabama, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Boise State
My Top 5: LSU, Alabama, Oklahoma State, Boise State, Wisconsin
The team most discussed around the top 5 is Boise State, which despite winning and winning big has continued to slide in the eyes of the coaches. Stanford on the other hand has slid out of the top five everywhere except the coaches due to a very weak schedule with no marquee win. LSU, Alabama and Oklahoma still are the class of the top 5 and the BCS loves Oklahoma State most likely based on wins against A&M and Texas. Last top 5 thought can someone tell me why everyone loves Texas they've played two good teams and been beaten soundly in both.
AP 6-10: Oklahoma State, Stanford, Clemson, Oregon, Arkansas
Coaches' 6-10: Oklahoma State, Boise State, Clemson (Tied), Oregon (Tied), Arkansas
Harris 6-10: Oklahoma State, Stanford, Clemson, Oregon, Arkansas
BCS 6-10: Wisconsin, Clemson, Stanford, Arkansas, Oregon
My 6-10: Stanford, Oklahoma State, Oregon, Clemson, Kansas State
I switched Oregon and Clemson because I think Oregon is a better team both on offense and defense. I have Kansas State the highest because they've impressed me with their victories over the past 4-5 weeks and have proven to deserve a low end top 10 rank. I understand the argument for Arkansas with teams in front of them losing this week but I just thought the undefeated Kansas State team was more worthy of the last spot in the top 10.
AP 11-15: West Virginia, Kansas State, Nebraska, South Carolina, Michigan State
Coaches' 11-15: Nebraska, South Carolina, Michigan State, West Virginia (Tied), Virginia Tech (Tied)
Harris 11-15: Nebraska, Kansas State, South Carolina, West Virginia, Michigan State
BCS 11-15: Kansas State, Nebraska, South Carolina, West Virginia
My 11-16: Arkansas, South Carolina, Virginia Tech, Nebraska, West Virginia
I think Nebraska & West Virginia are a little too high but I'm not sure where you can knock them down to right now seeing as they've both won the games they have been expected to win but none that you really say yeah that team has impressed me. South Carolina has impressed with a couple of victories but may be in some big trouble soon with the loss of their in offense in the form of Marcus Lattimore.
AP 16-20: Virginia Tech, Texas A&M, Michigan, Auburn
Coaches' 16-20: Kansas State, Michigan, Texas A&M, Georgia Tech, Houston
Harris 16-20: Virginia Tech, Michigan, Georgia Tech, Texas A&M, Illinios
BCS 16-20: Michigan State, Texas A&M, Michigan, Houston
My 16-20: Texas A&M, Michigan State, Houston, Penn State, Georgia Tech
Apparently if you weren't highly thought of 7 weeks ago by the coaches you're nothing, Kansas State has done everything right except be highly thought of in the preseason. I don't understand the love for Michigan, in their one good win they beat a non-top 25 team that out-played them for most of the game. Otherwise I think the 16-20 range is pretty standard.
AP 21-25: Houston, Washington, Illinois, Arizona State (Tied), Georgia (Tied)
Coaches' 21-25: Illinois, Penn State, Auburn, Washington, Arizona State
Harris 21-25: Auburn, Houston, Arizona State, Penn State, Washington
BCS 21-25: Penn State, Georgia Tech, Illinois, Texas, Washington
My 21-25: Michigan, Washington, SMU, Auburn, Illinois
This is the hardest tier each week to judge and rank because their is such similarity across the teams that you would put here. This week I gave the nods to Washington, SMU and Auburn to move into the top 25. Auburn moves back up because they have quality wins and their losses are games they were suppose to lose, Washington has been better than most expected especially on offense with Keith Price. SMU is the team that will surprise the most people so hear me out, their only loss is to a top 20 Texas A&M squad in the season opener, but their last two games have been a road victory over TCU and a home win over UCF the media non-AQ darling and a good team. SMU may make me look foolish in a tough road game at Southern Miss next week but I think this team has the opportunity to win Conference USA. Now for the teams I left out, what has Arizona State, Georgia or Texas shown us that warrants them to be in the top 25 this season. If I had to choose one I guess Georgia has made the biggest strides towards returning but I just don't think they have done enough to warrant an inclusion.
I'm thinking of adding a conference race column to keep up with teams resumes and the likes, plus my weekly picks column will be up Wednesday or Thursday. As always would love to hear your thoughts and suggestions in the comments section below.